Clean Beauty Is a Scam and Won't Give Us Safer Products | Lab Muffin Beauty Science


Clean Beauty Is a Scam and Won't Give Us Safer Products | Lab Muffin Beauty Science

Clean beauty ignores the very basics of ingredient safety. Here’s how it gets everything wrong, and how safety assessments …

Clean beauty products

#Clean #Beauty #Scam #Won39t #Give #Safer #Products #Lab #Muffin #Beauty #Science

Acne treatment solutionsAnti-aging skincareAt-home spa treatmentsBeauty myths debunkedBest skincare productsBest supplements for hair growthBest vitamins for skinClean beauty productsCruelty-free beauty brandsDIY beauty treatmentsEffective sunscreen applicationEssential oils for beautyFitness and beauty connectionHealthy hair care routineHealthy lifestyle habitsHolistic health tipsHydrating face masksImportance of hydrationMakeup tips for beginnersMindfulness and beautyNatural beauty tipsNutrition for glowing skinOrganic makeup brandsProfessional skincare treatmentsSeasonal skincare routinesSkin type guideStress relief techniquesTop superfoods for skinVegan skincare optionsWellness trends 2024
Comments (35)
Add Comment
  • @dianacajamarca6320

    I was a former employee of Credo and I began watching you Michelle about three months ago and I bought your book, I have been blown away about many of the truths of the clean beauty industry brands but because I had to sell those products sometimes I wouldn’t sell certain products because it’s formulation was “clean” but loaded with citrus oils or essential oils, even I began to experience a lot of clogged pores and realized I was using to much rich products on my skin that was all natural, clean, safe, non toxic yet it was clogging my pores. I then began to switch to more water based products and limit the use of fatty acids in my skincare routine, I began exploring brands like good molecules, naturium, Facetheory, peach&lily, purito, beauty of joseon, Farmacy, Skinfix. “Clean beauty” brands I do love is Dr Roger’s, Klur, Bloomeffects, Le Purnier, 54 Thrones, Iota, African Botanics (some), Marie Veronique, Tata Harper (some, mainly her super kind line). Happy I have left that position and are looking for new beginnings.

  • @flatflo

    0:49 I really thought you said "If you like nerding out about the science behind beauty products , click the like, the aubscribe, and click the NERDIFICATION bell so you dont miss any videos."

    Im in the US and love Australasian accents but often need to rewind and listen cloaer!

  • @ThePettipas

    Do you have an update 3y later? It seems most products now are paraben free. New preservatives with research?

  • @1TieDye1

    Not taking out the ear rings 😂

  • @valaineperry

    Great video, very helpful. More scientifically aware and thoughtful side of people pursuing "clean beauty" land more on the side of understanding all this, but feeling that a lot of ingredients commonly used haven't been tested or researched enough, or that safety standards didn't take enough into account, or manufacturing isn't regulated enough.

  • @GenerationJonesi

    People think 'natural' means 'nice' or 'safe'. Mother Nature has shown us more than once that 'natural' can be pretty dangerous. And, vice versa, synthetic ingredients can be safe.

  • @triciaroy

    I recently discovered your channel and am finding it eye-opening. I am embarrassed to admit I’ve fallen for a lot of the “clean beauty” or “clean eating” pseudoscience. Do you ever discuss food additives, supplements, or do you stick within the cosmetics realm? Do you have any videos on fragrance/perfume? Cheers

  • @user-ih2fq1ck2q

    Herbivore is the best example of products without preservatives that develop horrible mold growth. You can find shocking images of their products with mold growth, including brand new products from the store that already have mold growth before customer purchase

  • @brandyypine7767

    I use/used ewg to address the anxiety of are products harmful, drying, risk, etc (ethically made, environmentally responsible), but if ingredients and dosages are the information that would actually address that anxiety, I have a new concern. What about ingredients that are driven by corporate greed I.e. lead in the spices so it weighs more and they can sell more inventory, or the ingredients that add soap bubbles for a thick lather but end of stripping your hair of too much oil so you think it’s cleaner and buy that product instead of the one that doesn’t lather but isn’t as stripping (or is that one a myth) I guess without a reference db or a degree I feel more helpless, so is my fear unwarranted or are there resources /practices you stand by instead of green, clean, organic, ewg certified etc labelling? Thoughts anyone? (P.s. I only found you today so if you have a video on it – somebody tell me please)

  • @cedargrace

    Clean beauty is a cult 🤭 my friend refused to listen to my experience with scientificly backed skincare for years. Now she’s asking what I’ve been using on my skin bc it looks so good. 🤷🏻‍♀️

  • @sharroon7574

    Yvonne Burkhart is making quite a fuss about pthalates and parabens potentially contributing to breast cancer. Please look at her claims and break it down for us. She claims that non-profit funded a study etc.

  • @katerinab5099

    As for parabens – they are used in very small amount in cosmetics as you said. True. But what I am afraid of , is that there is not much information about accumulation of parabens in your skin and organs trough years. In big amounts parabens can be very dangerous (cancer risk or changes in genitals in animal studies). Do you have any thoughts on this? Tnx!

  • @bea3336

    What about non biodegradable microplastics that are great for sensorial reasons usually sitting up the top of the inci lists and ultimately end up in our oceans? With your expertise can you expand on this? Polymers etc are great functional ingredients but have no real skin care attributes. What are your thoughts?

  • @feli3331

    This makes so much sense now. Last year I had a quite bad reaction after using some "97% natural ingredients" face cream. My face skin is really sensitive and I tried different products after that, also "eco" stuff or "for sensitive skin" but most of them made my skin itch or red.
    Couldn't be perfume in general cause I used a specific handcream on my face which is scented but my skin had no problem with it.
    But after watching your videos I might have a clue what the issue is. The not so well known and overdosed alternative ingredients…
    I never was so much into skin care but I've heard from friends that korean skin care products are often very good. And I tried the Dynasty cream from BoJ which is great. 🤩👍🏼 No irritation, good hydration and no annoying smell.

  • @extremelyhappysimmer

    Was that a tumblr vanilla extract cake reference? 👀👀👀 idk if it was on this vid ive been watching a bunch of them

  • @alexandrahill580

    Genuine question for you: I have tried a lot of "dirty" beauty as it is referred to in this video. I have hypersensitive skin and peri-oral dermatitis (that started when I started wearing makeup as a teen). I have tried skincare that is for eczema, babies, rosacea, sensitive-skin, you name it, and I have not been able to rectify the issue. The ONLY thing that has worked has been using "clean beauty", as in products that are entirely botanically based. What might you recommend to someone like me who seems to be sensitive to anything that is "chemical", but wants to use products that actually work? Thanks! Love your videos.

  • @s.b.4206

    Sending this to my poor mom who was pressured into downloading the yuka app 😩

  • @im19ice3

    i know you're not an enviromental scientist so you might be limited in this topic, but i wonder about the validity of concerns regarding parabens or sulfates ending up in the ocean for example, when taken by the drain; i dont know if during the application, with the water and all, the chemicals change at all or what would be done to them at a water treatment plant, in general the hazards that aren't about direct human contact.

  • @HolldollMcG

    If you sell shirts or hoodies that say "I ❤️ Parabens" I will buy. Please. I need this.

  • @LogarAcc

    It makes me so happy seeing more & more genuine scientists with critical-thinking on social media. I know, legit scientists usually don't have the time and energy to have a second job on social media (and many are just big introverts, like myself), but every bit of reliable information you share is appreciated and very much needed.

  • @samilc

    Not skincare related but I used to buy schwarzkopf products for years, when they went 100% clean and vegan and all that stuff I noticed they didnt work as good as they used to anymore, I went back to buying drugstore hairproducts and they worked 10 times better for me.

  • @sarah-uc7pw

    So they can break the law then? If something's marketed as "clean" because they removed certain preservatives, are they allowed to sell it without an adequate level of preservation? Like, if chemists or whatever have tested all these ingredients like parabens to make sure they're absolutely safe in the quantities found in the products, haven't the "clean" products also been tested for safety with the degree of preservatives that they have? Don't they also have to pass whatever the country's safety regulations are? I'm not trying to sound contrary or anything – I'm just not sure what to conclude on this subject. Like, I get that "clean" products might not be safer, but are they actually LESS safe? Like if people are wary of parabens, and they can replace them with something else, what's wrong with that? Haven't the replacement chemicals been tested for safety?

    By the way, I'm not talking about "clean" beauty you'd find at a mom-and-pop hippy shop on a beach boardwalk or anything, I'm talking about brands like Tatcha, Drunk Elephant, Farmacy, Glow Recipe.

  • @AgentSmith1902

    Hi Michelle! Found your channel through Reddit and I've been watching your videos eversince I changed shampoos because of my scalp! Since you're Australian, have you heard of Sukin? Love your content and thank you for sharing knowledge 😀

  • @alexishooker2437

    So glad I’ve discovered your channel! As a PhD student I’ve come to understand the importance and benefits of finding research backed claims to things and not just running with what’s all over the internet.

  • @Plumarin

    Ive never watched a more brain rotting video. YOU CLAIM A PHD but are unable to cite any studies or facts related to Parabans !!? You talked about parabens being cited as "technically true" to cause increase risk of cancer ect and then go to state "if you know how to Interpret the data" and you never stated a SINGLE FACT OR DATA POINT TO SUPPORT UR CLAIM ABOUT PARABANS . I am literally shook you even made this video. It adds NOTHING OF VALUE TO THE SCIENTIFIC COMMUNITY maybe besides wasting my time for views.

  • @jubestube99

    All the teeny tiny risks of all the products one person may use every day (including food eaten that contains all sorts of nasties) all of this adds up to one big risk 🤦‍♀️😱

  • @RaeRaesRaveReviews

    Ive watched a couple of these "clean beauty=scam" videos and none of them address forever chemicals and the fact that they bio-accumulate. So even if makeup products contain a very small, non-hazardous amount of PFAS and PFOS, that amount bio-accumulates over time. I appreciate that clean beauty movement encourages transparency in ingredients. I would like to use makeup without forever chemicals — not just for my health but for the long term health of all life on the planet, I wish to not support the production of those chemicals.

  • @mikegan9382

    Never care abt clean beauty. I only use La Mer and La Prairie.

  • @soof3993

    You bring up a good point about alternative preservatives, but I think your fundamental argument is flawed. Science is always changing, and we might find out tomorrow that something is quite riskier than we think it is. What is the harm of avoiding it altogether?

    It seems like the same argument one would make for why its okay to consume heavy metals or pesticides in our food. “Well the FDA said it’s safe in these levels, so whats the problem?” Avoiding these foreign particles altogether is not a scam or a waste of time. Its potentially good for our bodies, and at the least it wont harm us. Additionally, it might push companies to work on safer alternatives.

    You then end your video by saying that your growing account is proof that people can “believe in the science”. For a so-called science believer, you fail to consider another likely hypothesis of why your channel is growing: people want to hear validation that their favorite products are safe.

  • @1alazydaisy

    Clean beauty fanatics = full climate change believers

  • @ToraPaint

    Thank you so much for this video! I'm very new to this whole thing and I was going absolutely insane bcs i found a list of ingredients that you should avoid in sunscreen only to realise that almost all the sunscreens i've seen people recommend have those ingredients.
    I feel a little better now so thank you!!

  • @Rachaelshaw7

    Garath avoids chemicals.
    Garath survives on dark matter.

    Good on you Garath 👍🏻